2026 Toyota Tacoma vs Nissan Frontier

Side by side

2026 Toyota Tacoma vs Nissan Frontier

The 2026 Tacoma tops out at 23 mpg combined in EPA testing, 2 more than the Frontier at 21. NHTSA lists 0 recall campaigns for the 2026 Tacoma and 1 for the Frontier.

Photo: Charles from Port Chester, New York, CC0, Wikimedia Commons

2026 Toyota Tacoma vs Nissan Frontier in numbers

2026 Toyota Tacoma 2026 Nissan Frontier
Best combined EPA rating 23 mpg (2.4L 4-cyl turbo, RWD) 21 mpg (3.8L 6-cyl, RWD)
Combined range, all versions 20–23 mpg 18–21 mpg
Best version city / hwy 21 / 26 19 / 24
Engines (EPA) 2.4L 4-cyl turbo, 2.4L 4-cyl turbo hybrid 3.8L 6-cyl
Drive types 4WD, Part-time 4WD, RWD Part-time 4WD, RWD
EPA fuel cost per year $2,700–$3,100 $2,950–$3,450
NHTSA recalls 0 1
Owner complaints 18 12
NHTSA overall stars 4 of 5 4 of 5

Updated November 22, 2026. Sources: EPA fueleconomy.gov ratings for the 2026 Tacoma and Frontier; NHTSA recalls, complaints and crash ratings through November 19, 2026.

Tacoma has 1 fewer recall

NHTSA lists 0 recall campaigns for the 2026 Tacoma and 1 for the Frontier. Together the 2026 Tacoma and Frontier have 1 campaigns.

NHTSA lists no recall campaigns for the 2026 Tacoma, unlike the Frontier.

Latest 2026 Frontier recalls, out of 1, for comparison with the Tacoma:

  • Jan 20, 2026, Latches/Locks/Linkages, Doors, Latch (NHTSA 26V023000, 26,432 vehicles)

See the 2026 Frontier recall list.

Tacoma gets 2 more mpg on its best version

The 2026 Tacoma tops out at 23 mpg combined in EPA testing, 2 more than the Frontier at 21. EPA fuel cost estimates run $2,700 to $3,100 a year for the Tacoma and $2,950 to $3,450 a year for the Frontier. The Tacoma has 2 engine versions in the EPA listings and the Frontier has 1.

Next to the Frontier, the 2026 Tacoma offers 2.4L 4-cyl turbo 23 combined (21 city, 26 highway, RWD); 2.4L 4-cyl turbo hybrid 23 combined (22 city, 24 highway, 4WD).

Next to the Tacoma, the 2026 Frontier offers 3.8L 6-cyl 21 combined (19 city, 24 highway, RWD).

Work out what a 2026 Tacoma or Frontier would cost you with your own miles and fuel price.

Frontier draws fewer owner complaints

The 2026 Tacoma has 18 owner complaints at NHTSA; the most named areas are power train (4), engine (3), electrical system (2).

The 2026 Frontier has 12 owner complaints at NHTSA; the most named areas are power train (4), unknown or other (2), fuel system, gasoline (1).

Reports about the 2026 Tacoma and Frontier keep arriving for years after sale.

2026 crash ratings for the Tacoma and Frontier

The Tacoma rates 4 of 5 stars overall across 3 tested versions, and the Frontier rates 4 of 5 stars overall across 2 tested versions. These are the 2026 Tacoma and Frontier results from NHTSA 5-Star Safety Ratings.

Engines and drive for the 2026 Tacoma and Frontier

The Tacoma comes with 2.4L 4-cyl turbo, 2.4L 4-cyl turbo hybrid and 4WD, Part-time 4WD, RWD drive. The Frontier comes with 3.8L 6-cyl and Part-time 4WD, RWD drive.

Tacoma and Frontier from 2023 to 2026

Best combined EPA rating and NHTSA recall campaigns for each year both models have a page.

Year Toyota Tacoma Nissan Frontier
2026 23 mpg, 0 recalls 21 mpg, 1 recall
2025 23 mpg, 5 recalls 21 mpg, 3 recalls
2024 24 mpg, 6 recalls 21 mpg, 3 recalls
2023 21 mpg, 4 recalls 21 mpg, 1 recall

Compare the Tacoma or Frontier with another year or vehicle

Change either side to put a different year of the Tacoma or Frontier, or any other model, next to it.

First vehicle

Second vehicle

What to compare

Figures for 2026 Toyota Tacoma and any vehicle you pick come from EPA fueleconomy.gov, NHTSA recall, complaint and crash data, and the makers’ own towing guides and owner’s manuals. Updated November 22, 2026.

More on the Tacoma and Frontier

Model pages: Toyota Tacoma by year, Nissan Frontier by year. Brands: Toyota models, Nissan models.

Related comparisons: Tacoma vs Tundra, Tacoma vs Colorado, Tacoma vs Ranger, Tacoma vs Gladiator, Tacoma vs Ridgeline, Frontier vs Colorado.

2026 Toyota Tacoma vs Nissan Frontier questions

Which gets better gas mileage, the 2026 Tacoma or Frontier?

The 2026 Tacoma tops out at 23 mpg combined in EPA testing, 2 more than the Frontier at 21.

Which has more recalls, the 2026 Tacoma or Frontier?

NHTSA lists 0 recall campaigns for the 2026 Tacoma and 1 for the Frontier.

Does the 2026 Tacoma or Frontier have more owner complaints?

NHTSA has 18 complaints for the 2026 Tacoma and 12 for the 2026 Frontier.

Is the 2026 Tacoma or Frontier safer in a crash?

NHTSA overall ratings for 2026: Tacoma 4 of 5, Frontier 4 of 5.

What engines do the 2026 Tacoma and Frontier offer?

Tacoma: 2.4L 4-cyl turbo, 2.4L 4-cyl turbo hybrid. Frontier: 3.8L 6-cyl.

Which costs less to fuel, the Tacoma or Frontier?

EPA yearly fuel cost estimates for 2026: Tacoma $2,700–$3,100, Frontier $2,950–$3,450.

Can you get the 2026 Tacoma or Frontier with 4WD or AWD?

Drive types in the EPA data. Tacoma: 4WD, Part-time 4WD, RWD. Frontier: Part-time 4WD, RWD.